Skip to Main content
  • Proper Pizza

Currently not accepting online orders

Proper Pizza 2283 Ringling Boulevard

2283 Ringling Boulevard, Sarasota, FL
Pizza Menu🍕
Main Menu 🍽️
Catering Menu 🚗
N/A Beverages 🥤
Happy Hour Food
Happy Hour Drinks

Pizza Menu🍕

14" Pizzas

  • 14" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Regular Pizza 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $16.00
  • Pep Pizza 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni
    $18.00
  • Honey Badger 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, herbed ricotta, four chili blend, Mike's hot honey
    $24.00
  • Buffalo Soldier 14"

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese
    $24.00
  • Parmageddon 14"

    Red sauce, shredded mozzarella, breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, basil.
    $24.00
  • White Iverson 14"

    Smoked mozzarella, herbed ricotta, garlic oil, parmigiano reggiano, parsley
    $22.00
  • EBTKS 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives.
    $24.00
  • Meaty Boi 14"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, wagyu meatballs
    $24.00
  • Proper Pizza 14"

    $24.00
  • Queen Margherita 14"

    Red Sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil.
    $24.00
  • The Goat 14"

    EVOO, shredded mozzarella, goat cheese, roasted garlic, honey
    $22.00
  • Tie Dye Pizza 14"

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $22.00

18" Pizza

  • 18" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Regular Pizza 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $24.00
  • Pep Pizza 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni
    $26.00
  • Honey Badger 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, herbed ricotta, four chili blend, Mike's hot honey
    $34.00
  • Buffalo Soldier 18"

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese
    $34.00
  • Parmageddon 18"

    Red sauce, shredded mozzarella, breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, basil.
    $34.00
  • White Iverson 18"

    Smoked mozzarella, herbed ricotta, garlic oil, parmigiano reggiano, parsley
    $32.00
  • EBTKS 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives.
    $34.00
  • Meaty Boi 18"

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, wagyu meatballs
    $34.00
  • Proper Pizza 18"

    $34.00
  • Queen Margherita 18"

    Red Sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil.
    $34.00
  • The Goat 18"

    EVOO, shredded mozzarella, goat cheese, roasted garlic, honey
    $32.00
  • Tie Dye Pizza 18"

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $32.00

Sicilian Pizza

  • Sicilian Pizza Plain (10" Square)

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella
    $18.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Double Pepperoni (10" Square)

    Red Sauce, shredded mozzarella, double pepperoni, parmigiano reggiano, fresh basil
    $22.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Tie Dye (10" Square)

    Shredded mozzarella, vodka sauce, marinara sauce, pesto sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $24.00
  • Sicilian Pizza Buffalo Soldier (10" Square)

    Shredded mozzarella, buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, choice of ranch or blue cheese.
    $24.00

XL Pizzas

  • XL Plain Cheese Pizza

    $21.00
  • XL Pepperoni Pizza

    $23.00
  • XL Veggie Pizza

    $30.00
  • XL Supreme Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Meatlovers Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Hot Honey Pizza

    $34.00
  • XL Margherita Pizza

    $30.00
  • XL White Pizza

    $32.00
  • XL Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $34.00

Other Pizzas

  • 10" Plain Cheese Pizza

    Added to fulfill sizing request.
  • Burrata Bomb (Grandma Square)

    Red Sauce, four pepper chili blend, pepperoni, burrata, Mike's hot honey
    $32.00
  • Brooklyn Square (16" Square)

    Seasoned crust, red sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil, parmigiano reggiano
    $28.00
  • Nduja Pie

    Red sauce, nduja sausage, burrata, crushed pistachios, parmigiano reggiano.
    $32.00
  • Teddy's Truffle Pie

    Shredded mozz, whipped herbed ricotta, sautéed chanterelle mushrooms, black summer truffles, truffle honey, sea salt

Kids Pizza

  • Kids Cheese Pizza

    Kid's portioned cheese pizza
    $10.00

Main Menu 🍽️

Starters

  • HTB

    Heirloom tomatoes, burrata, pesto, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction, crushed pistachios and micro basil. Served with toasted focaccia
    $14.00
  • Fries With Benefits

    White truffle, parmesan cheese, parsley, fried in pure beef tallow
    $12.00
  • Papa Chef’s Meatballs

    Homemade 100% grass-fed wagyu beef meatballs, marinara, parmigiano reggiano
    $12.00
  • Squid Games

    Lightly breaded calamari, shishito peppers, served with marinara and roasted garlic aioli
    $15.00
  • Sunshine Caesar

    Little gem lettuce, parmigiano reggiano, Sicilian breadcrumbs, house made anchovy caesar dressing
    $14.00
  • Twisted Sisters

    Garlic knots, house made garlic parm sauce, side of marinara
    $8.00
  • Rosemary’s Baby

    Fluffy and crispy house made focaccia
    $10.00

Wings

  • Wings (10 Piece)

    10 wings with your choice of sauce
    $18.00
  • Wings (20 Piece)

    20 wings with your choice of sauce
    $35.00

Sandwiches

  • The Russell

    Choice of hand breaded chicken cutlet or grilled chicken breast, chopped romaine, Sicilian breadcrumbs, freshly grated parmigiano reggiano, house made Caesar dressing, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Big Z

    House made wagyu beef meatballs, marinara, shredded mozzarella cheese, parmigiano reggiano, seeded roll
    $18.00
  • The G

    Pepperoni, salami, mortadella, capicola, prosciutto di Parma, provolone, shaved lettuce, sliced tomato, sweet onion, roasted red pepper, pepperoncini, oil and vinegar, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Alfie

    All natural turkey, house made pesto aioli, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, arugula, focaccia
    $16.00
  • The Matty B

    Pistacchio mortadella, burrata, pistachio cream, parmigiano reggiano, crushed pistachios, focaccia
    $16.00

Calzones

  • Calzone

    3 topping max. Deep fried or baked with mozzarella and ricotta
    $15.00

Pasta

  • The Sir

    Tiger shrimp, spicy tomato sauce, Calabrian chili
    $26.00
  • The Mam

    Imported pecorino romano, tellicherry black pepper
    $19.00
  • Why's It Called Alfredo?

    Garlic confit, fresh thyme, creamy alfredo sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $19.00
  • La Rosa

    Heirloom cherry tomato, vodka sauce, parmigiano reggiano
    $19.00
  • Meaty Gurl

    100% grass fed wagyu beef, celery, carrot, tomato sauce
    $22.00
  • Tie Dye Pasta

    Hand breaded harvestland organic chicken cutlet, marinara, vodka sauce, basil pesto, burrata, micro basil, parmigiano reggiano, side of fresh pasta with vodka sauce
    $30.00
  • Traditional Pasta

    Hand breaded harvestland organic chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, micro basil, parmigiano reggiano, side of fresh pasta with marinara sauce
    $30.00
  • The Baked Z

    Rigatoni, bolognese, ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan, baked to perfection
    $22.00
  • Nonna Nola

    Bell peppers, onions, cajun cream sauce
    $19.00
  • Kids Pasta

    Buttered or marinara
    $8.00

Desserts

  • Mini Cannoli

    $2.00
  • New York Style Cheesecake

    Topped with a strawberry compote and house made whipped cream
  • Pistachio Panna Cotta

    Topped with roasted pistachios and house made whipped cream
  • Tiramisu

    Lady fingers, mascarpone cream, espresso
  • Sicilian Cannoli

    Housemade sweet ricotta with chocolate chips
  • Blood Orange Olive Oil Cake

    Served with whipped ricotta and honey

Catering Menu 🚗

Starters

  • Meatballs - Half Pan

    $40.00
  • Meatballs - Full Pan

    $80.00
  • Garlic Knots - Half Pan

    Served with marinara sauce
    $30.00
  • Garlic Knots - Full Pan

    Served with marinara sauce
    $60.00
  • Bone In Wings - 20pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $34.00
  • Bone In Wings - 50pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $80.00
  • Boneless Wings - 20pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $34.00
  • Boneless Wings - 50pcs

    Sauces: Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Buffalo-BBQ, Garlic Parm. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
    $80.00
  • Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Salad - Half Pan

    Served with Homemade Pesto Sauce, Micro Basil
    $50.00
  • Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Salad - Full Pan

    Served with Homemade Pesto Sauce, Micro Basil
    $100.00
  • Caesar Salad - Half Pan

    Romaine, Homemade Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Croutons.
    $35.00
  • Caesar Salad - Full Pan

    Romaine, Homemade Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Croutons.
    $70.00

Pasta

  • Penne Alfredo - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Alfredo - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Vodka - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Vodka - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Pesto - Half Pan

    $60.00
  • Penne Pesto - Full Pan

    $120.00
  • Penne Bolognese - Half Pan

    $70.00
  • Penne Bolognese - Full Pan

    $140.00
  • Penne Marinara - Half Pan

    $50.00
  • Penne Marinara - Full Pan

    $100.00
  • Penne Arrabiatta - Half Pan

    $50.00
  • Penne Arrabiatta - Full Pan

    $100.00
  • Baked Ziti - Half Pan

    $75.00
  • Baked Ziti - Full Pan

    $150.00

Desserts

  • Tiramisu - Half Pan

    $40.00
  • Tiramisu - Full Pan

    $80.00

N/A Beverages 🥤

Soda

  • Coke Can

    $2.00
  • Sprite Can

    Corrected from 'Spite Can'
    $2.00
  • Diet Coke Can

    $2.00

Water

  • Bottled Water

    $2.00

Happy Hour Food

Happy Hour

  • Tendies

    Vodka fondue
    $9.00
  • Pizza Montanara

    Fried pizza dough, red sauce, fresh mozz, truffle oil, parmigiano reggiano, basil
    $8.00
  • Mini Charcuterie Board

    Prosciutto, mortadella, parmesan, goat cheese, olives, almonds, fig jam, toasted focaccia
    $12.00
  • Chicken Parm Sliders (2)

    Chicken cutlet, marinara, fresh mozz, basil, garlic knot bun
    $9.00
  • Bruschetta

    Heirloom cherry tomatoes, EVOO, roasted garlic, fresh basil, balsamic reduction, parmigiano reggiano, micro basil.
    $8.00
  • Nduja Mussels

    PEI mussels, nduja, heirloom cherry tomatoes, shallots, garlic, white wine, fresh thyme, meyer lemon, served with grilled focaccia
    $12.00

Happy Hour Drinks

Wine

  • Wine (TBD) Glass

    Wine selection to be determined.
  • Wine (TBD) Bottle

    Wine selection to be determined.

Proper Pizza 18"

$34.00

Customize your item

18" Pizza Toppings

Select up to 10
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Proper Pizza Location and Hours

(518) 391-0218
2283 Ringling Boulevard, Sarasota, FL 34237
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 8AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement